Skip to main content
Home / News / HBC Lease Battle: $2.4M Cost Debate with Landlords

HBC Lease Battle: $2.4M Cost Debate with Landlords

January 23, 2026
Updated January 23, 2026 at 10:24 a.m.
3 min read
CityNews Toronto
Share:
Courtroom scene representing a legal dispute over lease agreements in Toronto.

Courtroom scene representing a legal dispute over lease agreements in Toronto.

In a recent development, landlords of Hudson's Bay properties in Toronto are demanding $2.4 million to cover expenses incurred during a legal battle over lease sales to B.C. billionaire Ruby Liu. The landlords, including Cadillac Fairview and Ivanhoé Cambridge, argue that the costs were unavoidable due to extensive court preparations and cross-examinations. Although some leases were approved for transfer in Liu's malls, others were blocked, prompting this financial claim against the collapsed retailer. This case highlights the complex dynamics of creditor protection and lease sales, particularly when landlords and retailers clash over property control.

"This case highlights the critical nature of clear legal strategies in lease disputes, particularly in creditor protection scenarios."

Legal Perspective: Understanding the financial and legal implications is essential for both landlords and tenants to protect their interests.

Key Takeaways

Landlords demand $2.4 million from Hudson's Bay for lease battle costs.

The dispute involved significant legal expenses due to court proceedings.

Outcome may influence future creditor protection cases and lease negotiations.

What This Means for Ontario Residents

For Ontario residents and businesses, this case underscores the challenges in lease negotiations and creditor protection processes. If landlords successfully recoup these costs, it may set a precedent, making businesses more cautious in future lease sales, potentially stalling deals that involve multiple stakeholders. This impacts not only large retailers like Hudson's Bay but could also affect smaller businesses and landlords who might face similar disputes. Understanding the legal landscape in such scenarios becomes crucial, especially for those involved in commercial lease agreements or considering expansion. Litigation Lawyers can provide guidance in navigating these complex legal terrains.

What You Should Do

1

Review all lease agreements thoroughly Urgent

Ensure clarity on terms and obligations to avoid disputes

2

Consult with a litigation lawyer Urgent

Get expert advice on potential legal strategies and outcomes

3

Document all communications and court filings

Maintain a detailed record for any legal proceedings

4

Understand your rights under creditor protection laws

Familiarize yourself with the legal framework affecting leases

5

Assess financial implications of lease disputes

Consider the potential costs and benefits of litigation

Your Rights and Options

Ontario residents involved in lease agreements, whether as landlords or tenants, have the right to seek legal advice to understand their obligations and protections under creditor protection laws. If you're facing a similar dispute, understanding the legal precedents and potential implications is vital. Consulting with experienced litigation lawyers can help clarify your position and strengthen your case, should you find yourself in court over lease issues.

Common Questions Answered

How UL Lawyers Can Help

Dealing with complex lease disputes can be overwhelming, especially when significant financial stakes are involved. At UL Lawyers, we understand the intricacies of lease agreements and creditor protection cases. Our team is dedicated to providing clear guidance tailored to your situation, helping you navigate the legal process with confidence. Whether you're a landlord or a tenant, reach out for a free consultation to explore your options and secure your interests without feeling pressured. Our legal team will make space to hear what happened, answer your questions in plain language, and offer a free consultation when you feel ready.

Facing a lease dispute? Our litigation team can help you navigate the complexities with confidence.

Important Legal Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult with a professional for advice on your specific situation.