Case snapshot
At a glance
- Case
- Can a Late Expert Report Be Admitted at Trial in Ontario?
- Court / Tribunal
- Ontario Superior Court of Justice
- Citation
- 2026 ONSC 6093 ↗
- Date
- October 28, 2026
- Area of law
- Litigation Law
- Key issue
- Whether a trial judge should grant leave under r. 53.08 to rely on a one-page supplementary psychiatric report served 39 days after the deadline in r. 53.03(3).
- Outcome
- Leave was granted. The court found that admitting the supplementary report caused no prejudice that could not be addressed through ordinary cross-examination, and that it would not delay the trial.
- Why it matters
- Parties in an Ontario civil jury trial need to know how a trial judge applies r. 53.03 and r. 53.08 when a supplementary expert report is served after the 45-day deadline.
Legal principle
The rule from this case
Rule 53.03(3) provides that an expert may not testify on an issue, except with leave of the trial judge, unless the substance of the testimony is set out in a report served under the rule, a supplementary report served at least 45 days before trial, or a responding supplementary report served at least 15 days before trial. Rule 53.03(4) allows the court to extend or abridge the time for service. Where those requirements have not been met, r. 53.08(1) requires the party responsible for the failure to satisfy the court that there is a reasonable explanation and that granting leave would neither cause prejudice that could not be compensated by costs or an adjournment, nor cause undue delay in the conduct of the trial. Following the Divisional Court in Pelrine, the trial judge applied that test contextually, with r. 1.04 and the interests of justice running through the analysis. A reasonable explanation is required, not a perfect one, and the explanation is not weighed in isolation. In this case the late material was a one-page supplementary report from the plaintiff's psychiatrist. After reassessing the plaintiff and reviewing updated medical records, she confirmed that the diagnoses and opinions in her June 28, 2024 report were unchanged. The report did not put a new opinion before the jury. The trial judge treated cross-examination on the medical records said to be inconsistent with that opinion as part of the ordinary trial process.
Important limits
What this does not mean
This decision does not mean that supplementary expert reports may be served late as a matter of course. The trial judge accepted that the report could and should have been obtained earlier, and treated compliance with r. 53.03 as important. Leave turned on the circumstances of this report: it was one page, it confirmed an existing opinion rather than advancing a new diagnosis or theory, the defendant could still cross-examine on the updated records, and admitting it would not delay the trial. The reasons also do not remove the need for a reasonable explanation. Under the approach in Pelrine, which this court applied, the explanation is assessed in context and must not overwhelm the rest of the analysis, but it remains part of the test. The court noted that the amendments to r. 53.08 were aimed at routine late service of expert reports, including late service for strategic reasons. A delay used to introduce a new theory or opinion shortly before trial would be a different application of the rule.
What happens if a supplementary expert report is served late in an Ontario civil trial?
A trial judge may still grant leave to rely on it if there is a reasonable explanation for the failure and granting leave would not cause non-compensable prejudice or undue delay. In Azzi v. Kelly, 2026 ONSC 6093 (CanLII) (full decision), the plaintiff moved for leave to rely on a supplementary psychiatric report served 39 days after the deadline in r. 53.03(3).
The action is a civil jury case brought by the plaintiff, Rana Azzi, against Tara Sweeney as litigation administrator for the estate of the late Donald Kelly. The motion, heard on October 26, 2026, was a request for leave under r. 53.08 to rely on a late supplementary expert report.
What test does the trial judge apply to a late supplementary report?
Rule 53.03(3) requires a supplementary expert report to be served at least 45 days before trial, unless the trial judge gives leave. A responding supplementary report must be served at least 15 days before trial. Rule 53.03(4) allows the court to extend or abridge the time for service on motion.
Where r. 53.03(3) has not been met, r. 53.08(1) governs leave. The party responsible for the failure must satisfy the court that there is a reasonable explanation, and that granting leave would neither cause prejudice that could not be compensated by costs or an adjournment, nor cause undue delay in the conduct of the trial.
The trial judge followed the Divisional Court’s approach in Pelrine v. Chung, 2026 ONSC 4362. The amended rule is stricter, but it is applied contextually. Rule 1.04 and the interests of justice run through the analysis. The rule requires a reasonable explanation, not a perfect one, and that explanation is not considered in isolation. The explanation also must not overwhelm the court’s function of deciding cases on their merits.
Does the content of the late report matter?
Yes. The nature of the report was an important consideration.
The defendant’s psychologist, Dr. David Prendergast, had assessed the plaintiff and delivered a report dated October 4, 2022. The plaintiff’s psychiatrist, Dr. Emily Gavett-Liu, assessed her and delivered a report dated June 28, 2024. Dr. Prendergast responded with an addendum dated August 16, 2024.
The trial, first scheduled for March 2025, was adjourned to October 2026 because judicial resources were not available. Dr. Gavett-Liu reassessed the plaintiff on September 17, 2026. Her supplementary report is dated October 5, 2026, and was served the next day. Apart from a schedule of the updated records she reviewed, the report is one page. She confirmed that, after the reassessment and that review, the diagnoses and opinions in the June 28, 2024 report were unchanged.
The parties agreed the supplementary report had to be served at least 45 days before trial, so by August 28, 2026. Service on October 6, 2026 was 39 days after that deadline. The trial judge accepted that the report could and should have been obtained earlier. The delay was not used to introduce a new theory or opinion. The report told the parties and the jury that, having considered the more recent information, Dr. Gavett-Liu maintained the opinion she had already given.
What prejudice did the court find?
The defendant argued that counsel would now have to consider the additional records Dr. Gavett-Liu reviewed and how they might be used in cross-examination. The trial judge did not treat that as prejudice caused by the supplementary report.
Dr. Gavett-Liu was being called as an r. 53.03 expert. The defendant was entitled to cross-examine her on the factual foundation for her opinion, including the plaintiff’s relevant medical records. The judge expected counsel, even without the supplementary report, to put to her any relevant record said to be inconsistent with or to undermine her opinion.
Admitting the report did not place a new opinion before the jury. It allowed Dr. Gavett-Liu to say that she had considered the updated medical information and that her opinion was unchanged. Excluding it would have left the jury with the June 2024 opinion without knowing whether the later information had altered it. The judge found no prejudice that could not be addressed through ordinary cross-examination, and no delay to the trial. Leave was granted.
How does this apply in an Ontario civil jury trial?
The ruling is about expert evidence at a civil jury trial. The practical points are the ones the trial judge used: the report was supplementary and one page long; it followed a reassessment and a review of updated medical records; it confirmed an existing psychiatric opinion rather than adding a diagnosis; and the other side could test that opinion by cross-examination.
For general information about civil disputes, see UL Lawyers’ litigation services. The firm also has city pages for Hamilton litigation and Burlington litigation.
What are the broader lessons about expert deadlines in Ontario civil cases?
The time limits in r. 53.03 are not optional. The trial judge said they are important and should be complied with. At the same time, Pelrine — which this court applied — warns against a mechanical refusal that gives the missed deadline disproportionate weight.
The court looks at the explanation for the delay, any prejudice or delay from late service, the surrounding circumstances, and the interests of justice together. Here, those factors favoured letting the jury hear the psychiatrist’s opinion on the medical information she had actually reviewed.
Questions and records to discuss with a lawyer
- Was the supplementary expert report served at least 45 days before the commencement of trial, and if not, how late was service?
- Does the late report advance a new diagnosis or opinion, or does it confirm an earlier opinion after a reassessment and a review of updated medical records?
- What explanation is offered for the late service, and can it be assessed together with the rest of the circumstances rather than in isolation?
- Can the other side cross-examine the expert on the medical records said to be inconsistent with the opinion?
- Would granting leave delay the trial, or would excluding the report leave the jury with an older opinion and no word on whether later records changed it?
If you have questions about expert evidence or procedural timelines in an Ontario civil action, you can reach UL Lawyers through our contact page.
This article is automated commentary on a public court decision and is for general information only — not legal advice. Decisions rely on facts unique to each case. If you are affected by a similar issue, contact a lawyer for advice specific to your situation.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Under r. 53.03(3) of the Rules of Civil Procedure, a supplementary expert report must be served at least 45 days before the commencement of trial. A responding supplementary report must be served at least 15 days before trial. Rule 53.03(4) lets the court extend or abridge that time. If the report is still late, leave under r. 53.08 is how the trial judge can allow the party to rely on it.
Yes. Where r. 53.03(3) has not been met, the trial judge may refuse leave under r. 53.08(1). The party seeking leave must show a reasonable explanation for the failure, and that granting leave would not cause prejudice that could not be compensated by costs or an adjournment, or undue delay in the conduct of the trial.
Not on the facts of this decision. The trial judge found that admitting the one-page report caused no prejudice that could not be addressed through ordinary cross-examination, and that it would not delay the trial. The report did not place a new opinion before the jury.