Skip to main content

Search the site

Case Note

Can You Sue Your Auto Insurer After a Property Damage Settlement in Ontario?

An Ontario court dismissed a claim for additional auto property damage compensation because the one-year limitation period had expired. Learn what this means for your rights.

6 min readReviewed by Sunish Rai Uppal

Case snapshot

At a glance

Case
Can You Sue Your Auto Insurer After a Property Damage Settlement in Ontario?
Court / Tribunal
Ontario Superior Court of Justice
Date
November 9, 2026
Area of law
Litigation Law
Key issue
Whether a claim for an additional "top-up" payment after an auto property damage settlement was barred by the one-year limitation period under Ontario insurance regulations, and whether relief from forfeiture could save the claim.
Outcome
The court granted summary judgment in favour of the insurer and dismissed the claim, finding it was time-barred and that no basis for equitable relief existed.
Why it matters
If you disagree with your auto insurer's property damage payout, Ontario's one-year limitation period starts running from the date of the accident — not from when the insurer formally denies a top-up request — so acting quickly is critical.

Legal principle

The rule from this case

Under Ontario Regulation 777/93, section 9(4) of the Insurance Act, a lawsuit over automobile property damage must be started within one year of the date the loss happened. The court found this wording is mandatory and unambiguous: the clock starts on the accident date, not on any later event such as a denial of a supplementary payment request. The discoverability principle — which can sometimes delay when a limitation period starts — was found not to apply here in the usual way. The court reasoned that discoverability in this context relates to when the claimant knew about the loss itself, not when a top-up claim was refused. Because the claimant knew about the loss and the insurer's position within roughly 90 days of the accident, the limitation period was not extended. The court also rejected a request for relief from forfeiture, finding no facts to support equitable intervention and no conduct by the insurer suggesting waiver.

Important limits

What this does not mean

This decision does not mean that discoverability can never affect a limitation period in insurance disputes. The court's ruling was specific to the property damage limitation period under the Insurance Act regulation, which uses mandatory language tying the start date to the accident itself. Different types of insurance claims — such as accident benefits or tort claims for personal injury — operate under different rules and timelines. The case also does not stand for the proposition that relief from forfeiture is never available in insurance limitation disputes. The court found no supporting facts on the record before it; a claimant with evidence of insurer conduct that caused delay or confusion might argue differently in different circumstances. Each situation turns on its own facts.

Can you claim more money from your insurer after settling an auto property damage claim?

You can try, but Ontario law sets a strict deadline for doing so. A 2026 Ontario Superior Court decision — Qusay Abduljaleel v. Desjardins Insurance Company, 2026 CanLII 119502 (ON SC) — dismissed a claim for an additional “top-up” payment after a property damage settlement because the claimant had missed the one-year limitation period. Understanding how that deadline works could protect your own claim.

What is the limitation period for auto property damage claims in Ontario?

The limitation period for automobile property damage claims in Ontario is one year from the date of the accident. The court applied Ontario Regulation 777/93, section 9(4) under the Insurance Act, which the court described as mandatory and unambiguous: the one-year period runs from the “happening of the loss” — meaning the accident date — not from any later event in the claims process.

This is different from the general two-year limitation period that applies to many other civil claims in Ontario. For auto property damage, the legislature chose a shorter, stricter window, and the court found no room to read flexibility into that language.

Does the discoverability rule delay the start of the limitation period?

In this case, the court found that discoverability did not extend the limitation period. Discoverability — a legal principle under the Limitations Act, 2002, section 5(1)(a) — can sometimes delay when a limitation period begins, if the claimant did not and could not reasonably have known about the claim earlier.

However, the court reasoned that in the context of this regulation, discoverability relates to when the claimant knew about the loss itself, not when a specific top-up request was denied. The claimant knew about the accident and the insurer’s position within approximately 90 days. That knowledge was enough to start the clock. The argument that the limitation period should only begin when the insurer refused the additional payment was rejected.

What is relief from forfeiture and why didn’t it apply here?

Relief from forfeiture is an equitable remedy that courts can use to excuse a party from losing their legal rights due to a technical breach — such as missing a deadline — when it would be unfair to enforce the strict rule. The claimant asked the court to apply this doctrine to allow the late claim to proceed.

The court declined. It found no facts on the record to support equitable intervention. Critically, the insurer had acted promptly throughout the claims process, and there was nothing to suggest the insurer had waived the limitation period or done anything to mislead the claimant about the deadline. Without those kinds of supporting facts, relief from forfeiture was unavailable.

How was the case decided without a full trial?

The court resolved the dispute through summary judgment under Rule 20.04(2)(a) of the Rules of Civil Procedure. Both parties agreed the matter could be determined on the existing record without a trial. The transaction and communications between the parties were well-documented, and the limitation issue was straightforward enough to resolve on the written evidence.

Summary judgment is appropriate when there is no genuine issue requiring a trial. Here, the limitation period question was a matter of law applied to undisputed facts about timing, making a trial unnecessary.

What does this mean if you have a dispute with your auto insurer over property damage?

The practical lesson is that the one-year clock starts ticking on the accident date, regardless of how long negotiations or settlement discussions take afterward. If you accept an initial payment but later believe you are owed more — whether because repair costs were higher than estimated or because new damage was discovered — you must start a legal proceeding within one year of the accident, not one year from the date of any denial.

Our Ontario litigation lawyers regularly advise clients on insurance disputes and limitation period questions. If you are in the Hamilton or Burlington area and have a property damage dispute with your insurer, it is worth speaking with counsel sooner rather than later — these deadlines can be unforgiving.

For clients in the Greater Toronto Area, our Toronto litigation team can also assist with insurance-related civil claims.

Questions and records to discuss with a lawyer

  • What is the exact date of the accident or loss, and has one year passed since that date?
  • What written communications did you receive from your insurer, and when did you first learn the insurer’s position on your claim?
  • Did you sign any release or settlement agreement, and if so, what did it cover?
  • Is there any documentation showing the insurer caused delay or gave assurances that affected when you pursued your claim?
  • Are there other types of claims arising from the same accident — such as accident benefits or personal injury — that have different limitation periods?

If you have questions about a property damage dispute or any other insurance matter, you are welcome to reach out to UL Lawyers through our contact page to discuss your circumstances.


This article is automated commentary on a public court decision and is for general information only — not legal advice. Decisions rely on facts unique to each case. If you are affected by a similar issue, contact a lawyer for advice specific to your situation.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Ready when you are

Get a clear next step.
No obligation.

A short call with our team gives you an honest read on your file — deadlines, documents, and what you can do next.

Explore litigation law