Case snapshot
At a glance
- Case
- Is Reporting Car Damage Notice for Accident Benefits in Ontario?
- Court / Tribunal
- ONLAT
- Date
- November 3, 2026
- Area of law
- Motor Vehicle Accident
- Key issue
- Whether a driver who reported a car accident and vehicle damage to his insurer, but said he was not injured, gave the notice of intention to claim accident benefits required by section 32(1) of the Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule.
- Outcome
- The Licence Appeal Tribunal found the driver had not given the required notice, held that the insurer was not obliged to send an accident benefits package, ruled him statute-barred, and dismissed his application.
- Why it matters
- Many people call their insurer after a crash only about vehicle damage, and this decision found that such a call does not by itself count as notice of a claim for injury-related accident benefits.
Legal principle
The rule from this case
Under section 32(1) of the Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule, as the tribunal applied it, a person who intends to apply for accident benefits must tell the insurer of that intention within seven days of the circumstances giving rise to the benefit, or as soon as practicable afterward. The tribunal held that reporting the accident and damage to the vehicle, while stating there were no injuries, did not satisfy this requirement. Relying on a 2026 Court of Appeal for Ontario decision that it described as binding, the tribunal also held that an insurer is not required to assume an accident benefits claim is coming when a person reports only property damage. Where no injuries and no intention to claim are reported, the insurer is not obliged to ask whether the person wants accident benefits or to send the application forms and explanation of benefits described in section 32(2).
Important limits
What this does not mean
This decision does not mean every late accident benefits claim is automatically barred. The Schedule, as summarized by the tribunal, allows a person who misses a time limit to remain entitled to benefits if they show a reasonable explanation for the delay, and the tribunal set out the principles used to assess such explanations. The outcome here turned on the specific facts, including recorded calls in which the driver said he was not injured. It also does not decide what happens where a person does mention injuries or a wish to claim accident benefits when first contacting the insurer. The tribunal's reasoning addressed a situation involving a report of property damage, no injuries and no stated intention to claim, and it should not be read as setting rules for other scenarios.
Is telling your insurer about a car accident enough to claim accident benefits in Ontario?
According to a recent Licence Appeal Tribunal decision, reporting the accident and vehicle damage alone is not enough if you do not report injuries or say you intend to claim accident benefits. The tribunal treated a property damage call and an accident benefits notice as two different things.
The decision is Ogunreti v Definity Insurance Company, 2026 CanLII 118444 (CanLII). It deals with a common situation: a driver calls the insurer the day after a crash, talks about the car, and only months later submits an application for injury-related benefits.
What happened in this case?
The driver contacted his insurer within days of the accident, but the tribunal found he reported only vehicle damage and said he was not injured. He later submitted an accident benefits application 155 days after the crash.
The accident took place in September 2024. The driver spoke with the insurer’s representatives the next day and again two days later, and the insurer opened a property damage claim. The insurer produced log notes and audio recordings from those calls in which, according to the decision, the driver reported the accident and damage to his vehicle and stated he had no injuries.
In February 2025, the driver gave the insurer a completed application for accident benefits (an OCF-1). The insurer argued he had not given timely notice and was barred from proceeding. The driver argued the delay was caused by his psychological injuries, his impaired functional abilities, and the insurer’s failure to send him an application package.
What is the 7-day notice rule for accident benefits?
The tribunal explained that a person intending to apply for accident benefits must notify the insurer of that intention within seven days, or as soon as practicable afterward. This comes from section 32(1) of the Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule.
The decision describes the steps that follow. Once the insurer receives notice, it must provide the application forms, a written explanation of available benefits, and information to help with the application. The person then has 30 days after receiving the forms to return a completed, signed application.
Because the insurer raised the notice issue, the tribunal said the burden was on the insurer to prove the driver had not complied. The tribunal ultimately found the driver notified the insurer about the accident itself, but did not report injuries or say he intended to claim accident benefits. On that basis, it concluded he had not complied with section 32(1).
Does an insurer have to send accident benefits forms if you report no injuries?
The tribunal held that the insurer was not required to send an accident benefits package where the driver reported property damage, no injuries and no intention to claim. It reached this conclusion by following a 2026 Court of Appeal for Ontario decision.
The driver relied on an earlier 2025 Divisional Court decision, which he said required insurers to ask about injuries, clarify what benefits a person wanted, and send the forms. The tribunal noted that this earlier decision had since been overturned by the Court of Appeal, and it described the Court of Appeal’s ruling as both persuasive and binding on it.
Applying that ruling, the tribunal said the insurer did not have to assume an accident benefits claim was coming just because the driver reported an accident and car damage. Since no injuries were reported, the insurer had no obligation to ask whether he was seeking accident benefits or to send him the forms and explanation of benefits. You can read more about how these benefits work on our accident benefits page.
Can you still get accident benefits if you missed the deadline?
The Schedule, as summarized by the tribunal, allows a person who misses a time limit to remain entitled to benefits if they have a reasonable explanation for the delay. That comes from section 34.
The tribunal listed the guiding principles drawn from earlier decisions:
- The explanation must first be credible before its reasonableness is assessed.
- The insured person bears the burden of proving a reasonable explanation.
- Not knowing the law, on its own, is not a reasonable explanation.
- The test considers both the person’s own characteristics and a reasonable-person standard.
- A lack of prejudice to the insurer does not automatically make an explanation reasonable.
- The assessment balances prejudice to the insurer, hardship to the claimant, and whether it is fair to relieve against the missed deadline.
In this case, the driver pointed to his psychological injuries and functional limitations. The written reasons set out the principles above but focus their analysis on the notice question and the insurer’s obligations. The tribunal concluded the driver was statute-barred and dismissed the application.
Why does the first call to your insurer matter so much?
In this decision, the content of the early calls, captured in log notes and audio recordings, was central to the outcome. The tribunal relied on that record to find that only a property damage claim was discussed.
Insurers often record and document these conversations. Where the record shows a person said they were not injured, this decision indicates the tribunal may treat that as the absence of notice of an accident benefits claim. People dealing with the aftermath of a collision can learn more about the process from our Ontario motor vehicle accident lawyers.
Questions and records to discuss with a lawyer
- Notes, emails or call records showing exactly what you told your insurer after the accident, and when.
- Whether you mentioned any injury, pain or medical treatment in early conversations with the insurer.
- Medical or other records that may help explain any delay in applying for accident benefits.
- Any forms, letters or explanation of benefits the insurer did or did not send you.
- How the notice and reasonable explanation rules described in this decision may apply to your own timeline.
If you have questions about accident benefits, notice requirements or a denied claim after a car accident in Ontario, you can reach UL Lawyers through our contact page to discuss your own circumstances.
This article is automated commentary on a public court decision and is for general information only — not legal advice. Decisions rely on facts unique to each case. If you are affected by a similar issue, contact a lawyer for advice specific to your situation.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
As the tribunal described section 32(1) of the Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule, notice of an intention to apply must be given within seven days of the circumstances giving rise to the benefit, or as soon as practicable afterward. After receiving the forms, the decision notes a person has 30 days to return a completed application.
In this decision, the tribunal held the insurer did not have to send forms where the driver reported only vehicle damage, no injuries and no intention to claim accident benefits. The tribunal followed a 2026 Court of Appeal for Ontario decision on this point.
The tribunal said the explanation must first be credible, the claimant must prove it, and ignorance of the law alone is not enough. The assessment considers personal circumstances, a reasonable-person standard, prejudice to the insurer, hardship to the claimant and overall fairness.