Skip to main content

Search the site

Case Note

When Can a Threshold Motion Wipe Out a Jury Award in Ontario?

An Ontario court granted a threshold motion and reduced a jury's damages award to nil. Learn what the threshold test means for motor vehicle injury claims.

6 min readReviewed by Sunish Rai Uppal2026 ONSC 6210 (CanLII) ↗

Case snapshot

At a glance

Case
When Can a Threshold Motion Wipe Out a Jury Award in Ontario?
Court / Tribunal
Ontario Superior Court of Justice
Date
November 2, 2026
Area of law
Motor Vehicle Accident
Key issue
Whether the injured person proved a permanent serious impairment of an important physical, mental, or psychological function sufficient to overcome the statutory threshold under the Insurance Act and its regulations.
Outcome
The threshold motion was granted and the jury's general damages and past income loss awards were reduced to nil after statutory deductibles and collateral benefit deductions were applied.
Why it matters
If you were injured in a car accident and a jury awarded you damages, a post-verdict threshold motion can still eliminate your recovery entirely — understanding how that process works is critical before trial.

Legal principle

The rule from this case

Ontario's Insurance Act creates a threshold that an injured person must clear before recovering general damages in a motor vehicle tort claim. The plaintiff bears the burden of proving, on a balance of probabilities, that the accident caused a permanent serious impairment of an important physical, mental, or psychological function. That determination requires physician evidence and corroborating evidence meeting the standards set out in Ontario Regulation 381/03. The threshold motion is decided by the judge after the jury returns its verdict, and the judge is not bound by the jury's factual findings. As recognized in this decision — consistent with the approach in G.W. v. Rawlins — the judge may draw independent factual inferences from the expert evidence and the full trial record when assessing functional impairment, its seriousness, and whether it is causally linked to the accident. Even where a jury awards substantial damages, the judge may conclude the threshold has not been met and reduce the award to nil. Statutory deductibles and collateral benefit deductions under sections 267.5 and 267.8 of the Insurance Act are then applied on top of that determination, which can further reduce or eliminate what remains.

Important limits

What this does not mean

This decision does not mean that jury verdicts in motor vehicle cases are meaningless or that judges routinely override them. The threshold motion is a distinct legal step focused on a specific statutory question — whether the impairment meets the legal definition — not a general re-trial of the facts. The jury's role in assessing credibility and quantifying damages remains important for other aspects of the case. The outcome also does not mean that every injured person with a jury award will face the same result. Whether the threshold is met depends entirely on the medical evidence, the nature and permanence of the impairment, and how that evidence holds up against the regulatory criteria. Each case turns on its own facts and record.

What Is the Threshold Motion in an Ontario Car Accident Case?

The threshold motion is a post-verdict step in Ontario motor vehicle tort cases where the defendant asks the judge to decide whether the injured person’s impairment is serious enough to qualify for general damages under the Insurance Act. Even after a jury awards damages, the judge independently decides this question — and can reduce the award to nil if the threshold is not met.

In Smith v. Miller, 2026 ONSC 6210 (CanLII), the Ontario Superior Court granted the threshold motion and, after applying statutory deductibles and collateral benefit deductions, reduced both the general damages award and the past income loss award to nil.


What Does “Serious Impairment” Mean Under Ontario Law?

Serious impairment, for threshold purposes, means a permanent serious impairment of an important physical, mental, or psychological function. The injured person must prove this on a balance of probabilities using physician evidence and corroborating evidence, as required by Ontario Regulation 381/03, sections 4.1 to 4.3.

The court in this case assessed the full trial record — including expert reports and testimony — to determine whether the plaintiff’s functional limitations were real, serious, and causally connected to the accident. The court found they were not established to the required standard, which is why the motion succeeded.


Is the Judge Bound by What the Jury Decided?

No — the judge deciding a threshold motion is not bound by the jury’s factual findings. This is one of the most important and often misunderstood aspects of Ontario motor vehicle litigation.

The court in this case applied the approach recognized in G.W. v. Rawlins, which confirms that the judge may draw independent inferences from the evidence when evaluating impairment, seriousness, and causation. The jury’s role is to assess credibility and quantify damages; the judge’s role on the threshold motion is to apply a separate statutory test to the same record. These are different questions, and the answers can differ.


How Do Statutory Deductibles and Collateral Benefits Reduce a Car Accident Award?

Even where some damages survive the threshold analysis, Ontario’s Insurance Act further reduces what a plaintiff actually receives. Under section 267.5(7), a statutory deductible is applied to general damages awards below a set amount. Under section 267.8(1), collateral benefits — including accident benefits settlements — are deducted from certain heads of damages like past income loss.

In this case, the court applied the statutory deductible to the jury’s general damages figure and deducted the plaintiff’s accident benefits settlement from the past income loss award. Both amounts were reduced to nil as a result. If you have received accident benefits, those payments can directly offset what you recover at trial — a factor that needs to be part of any pre-trial strategy discussion. Our Ontario motor vehicle accident lawyers can explain how these deductions interact with your specific claim.


What Evidence Does a Plaintiff Need to Beat a Threshold Motion?

The plaintiff must lead physician evidence — typically from a treating or expert physician — that addresses the specific regulatory criteria for permanent serious impairment. Corroborating evidence is also required. The court will look at whether the functional impairment is real and measurable, whether it is serious in the context of the plaintiff’s life and activities, and whether the accident — not some other cause — is responsible.

In this case, the court assessed the expert and trial record and found the evidence insufficient on those points. This underscores why the quality and completeness of medical evidence matters enormously, not just for the jury portion of the trial but for the separate threshold determination that follows. If you are pursuing a claim in the Hamilton or Burlington area, our Burlington motor vehicle accident lawyers and Hamilton motor vehicle accident lawyers are familiar with how these evidentiary issues play out locally.


Does Winning at the Jury Stage Guarantee You Will Recover Damages?

No — a jury verdict in your favour is not a guarantee of recovery in an Ontario motor vehicle tort case. The threshold motion and the statutory deduction regime are both capable of reducing a jury award to nil, as this case demonstrates.

This does not mean pursuing a jury trial is the wrong strategy. It means that the litigation plan must account for the threshold motion from the beginning, not as an afterthought. Evidence that supports the jury’s damages assessment is not always the same evidence that satisfies the threshold’s specific legal requirements. Understanding that distinction early can affect how a case is prepared and presented. Information about accident benefits is also relevant here, since how those benefits are resolved can affect the deductions applied at trial.


Questions and Records to Discuss with a Lawyer

  • What medical records and physician reports document the nature and permanence of your impairment, and do they address the specific regulatory criteria for serious impairment?
  • Have you received any accident benefits payments or reached a settlement with your accident benefits insurer, and how might those amounts affect a future damages award?
  • What functional limitations has your impairment caused in your daily life, work, and activities, and how are those limitations documented?
  • Has causation — the link between the accident and your impairment — been clearly established in your medical evidence?
  • What is the current value of the statutory deductible, and how would it apply to the general damages range being discussed in your case?

If you have questions about how the threshold test or statutory deductions might affect your motor vehicle injury claim, you are welcome to reach out to UL Lawyers through /connect to discuss your circumstances.


This article is automated commentary on a public court decision and is for general information only — not legal advice. Decisions rely on facts unique to each case. If you are affected by a similar issue, contact a lawyer for advice specific to your situation.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Ready when you are

Get a clear next step.
No obligation.

A short call with our team gives you an honest read on your file — deadlines, documents, and what you can do next.

Explore motor vehicle accident