

Levels plans set the overall direction, but each person's path to permanent residence depends on specific program rules, deadlines and documents. Temporary residents should focus on keeping their status valid and their applications complete, whatever the political debate.
A heated exchange in the House of Commons this week between Conservative immigration critic Michelle Rempel Garner and federal Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Minister Lena Metlege Diab has spread well beyond Parliament Hill in Ottawa and drawn sharp reactions on social media. At the centre of the debate is the federal government's immigration levels plan, the roadmap that sets how many newcomers Canada intends to admit. For anyone following Canada's immigration policies, the back-and-forth shows how each side is framing the plan.
According to the Toronto Sun, the levels plan was published earlier this month as part of the federal budget. Soon after, Rempel Garner criticized it on social media. She wrote that Mark Carney had announced the highest level of permanent immigration in Canadian history and had tried to hide it. She added that this came on top of hundreds of thousands of new temporary immigrants that, in her words, Carney had also approved.
The criticism continued during Question Period on Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2026. Rempel Garner represents the riding of Calgary Nose Hill. She argued that bringing in what she called "close to a million new people next year" would overwhelm housing and health-care systems, which she described as already stretched.
Diab pushed back in the House and later posted a video of her response on X. In the clip, the minister said that most of the people who will become permanent residents next year are already living in Canada. She described them as people who work and pay taxes, including people caring for children in daycares, feeding people in their homes and helping in hospitals. She stressed that these people are already in the country on temporary status.
Diab's post drew harsh replies online, according to the Sun. The paper's headline features one all-caps response telling the government to "stop trying to gaslight us." A photo with the coverage shows Rempel Garner and Diab speaking during Question Period on Parliament Hill that Wednesday.
The available portion of the coverage does not give the plan's specific targets by program, so the exact figures behind each side's claims are not covered here. The debate comes down to two competing views. One holds that the plan adds pressure on housing and health care. The other, the minister's, holds that the plan largely moves people who already live in Canada from temporary to permanent status.
Key Takeaways
The federal immigration levels plan was published earlier this month as part of the federal budget
Conservative critic Michelle Rempel Garner argued the plan would strain housing and health care, citing close to a million new people next year
Immigration Minister Lena Metlege Diab said most of next year's new permanent residents already live in Canada on temporary status
Diab shared her Question Period response on X, where it drew harsh replies
Temporary residents in Ontario should watch for official IRCC program details rather than relying on political claims
UL Lawyers Insight
Many people in Ontario hold work permits, study permits or other temporary status, especially in Mississauga, Brampton and Toronto. For them, the federal levels plan is more than a political talking point. The minister said most new permanent residents next year are already in Canada on temporary status. If that holds, people living here now could make up a large share of the plan's permanent residence spaces. How those spaces are divided among programs, and who qualifies, will depend on details and rules from Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC).
The debate also signals that immigration numbers remain politically sensitive. Policies can shift when levels are debated, and program openings, draws and eligibility criteria can change. If you are planning a move from temporary to permanent residence, it helps to understand your options early. Reviewing reliable guides in our legal resource library is one place to start. Keep an eye on official announcements rather than social media claims from either side.
Action Checklist
What You Should Do
Confirm the expiry date of your work or study permitUrgent
Applying to extend before expiry generally preserves maintained status while IRCC processes your request
Identify which permanent residence pathways you may qualify for
Programs differ in eligibility, so know which ones match your work history, education and language results
Keep language test results and credential assessments current
Expired test results or assessments can delay or block an application when an opportunity opens
Gather proof of Canadian work experience and tax filings
Pay stubs, employment letters and tax records support applications that rely on time spent working in Canada
Follow official IRCC announcements on program details
Rely on government sources rather than social media claims when planning your application
Act quickly if you receive a refusalUrgent
Judicial review of an in-Canada decision generally must be filed within 15 days
Your Rights and Options
If you are in Ontario on a work or study permit and hoping to stay, your rights come from the federal Immigration and Refugee Protection Act and its regulations, not from political statements. A key protection is maintained status. If you apply to extend your permit before it expires, you can generally stay in Canada under your existing conditions while IRCC decides. Missing that window can leave you without status, so track your expiry dates closely, whatever happens with levels targets.
If IRCC refuses an application you made from inside Canada, you may be able to ask the Federal Court for judicial review. You generally need permission (leave) from the court, and the deadline is 15 days after you learn of the decision. Because these timelines are short, requesting a consultation soon after a refusal can help protect your options.
Common Questions Answered
How UL Lawyers Can Help
Seeing immigration numbers fought over in Parliament and online can be unsettling, especially when your own future in Canada feels tied to the outcome. You don't have to sort through the headlines alone. At UL Lawyers, we help newcomers and their families in Mississauga, Brampton, Toronto and across the GTA understand which pathways fit their situation, from work and study permits to permanent residency and sponsorship. We'll review your status, flag upcoming deadlines and explain your options in plain language. If you'd like clarity on where you stand, we offer a free consultation to talk it through.
Wondering how the new levels plan might affect your path from temporary status to permanent residence? Our team can review your situation and help you plan your next step.
Ontario Road Report
One email a week with the road and collision stories we covered in your city and across Ontario.
About this article:
Summary prepared with AI assistance from the linked source's reporting. Edited by UL Lawyers for Ontario context.
Accompanying images are AI-generated illustrations, not photographs of actual events or persons.
Important Legal Disclaimer
This page summarizes news coverage of a political debate over Canada's immigration levels plan and provides general information only. It is not legal advice and does not describe specific program targets or eligibility rules. Immigration rules and IRCC programs change often, and every case is different. Please consult a qualified immigration lawyer about your own work permit, study permit or permanent residence situation.
Source: TheTorontoSun
Named in this article? Request content removal