

A criminal charge is an accusation, not a conclusion. The Crown carries the burden of establishing every element beyond a reasonable doubt, and simply being present when something happens is not, by itself, a crime under Canadian law.
A 28-year-old Toronto man has been acquitted of murder in the shooting death of a 24-year-old former friend, more than three years after his arrest. According to the Toronto Star, the jury reached its verdict in late October 2026 after deliberating for about six hours. The courtroom was nearly empty, with only a few of his family members and one reporter present. For readers who follow legal developments in Ontario, the case stands out because of what the prosecution's case rested on.
The Star reports that the man was not the shooter. Instead, the Crown's case came down to a single action captured in a few frames of grainy surveillance video: an attempted kick. His defence lawyers, Monte MacGregor and Amanda Warth, describe their client as "completely innocent." They are now publicly asking how the case ever reached a jury.
Earlier in the case, a judge took what the Star calls the rare step of granting the man bail on a murder charge. At the time, she said it was possible that the trial would end with a finding that he had simply been present while someone else carried out the crime. The jury's verdict lined up with that view.
The events date back to April 14, 2023. The man was out near Bloor Street West and Ossington Avenue in Toronto with two close friends and a third man he described as an acquaintance. The group planned to buy marijuana before going their separate ways. As they approached a dispensary, a person on a scooter waved him across the street. He soon recognized the rider as a former friend.
The two had known each other for years, but he said the friendship faded during the pandemic. In his testimony, he said he had heard the former friend was spreading a rumour about him. The rumour claimed he had run from the scene when a mutual friend was stabbed during a robbery while the three were downtown celebrating New Year's in 2019. He testified that he responded by telling people what he said really happened: it was the other man who left, and he himself had also been stabbed. Outside the dispensary that night, he said, the former friend tried to confront him, and the two exchanged insults. He told the court the dispute did not matter to him and that he repeatedly asked to be left alone.
Surveillance clips show him walking away and appearing frustrated before entering the dispensary with the other three, while the man on the scooter waited outside. Inside, the group can be seen laughing and fist-bumping staff. Crown attorney Anna Tenhouse argued at trial that this footage showed he was preparing for a fight. When the jury foreperson announced the not guilty verdict, the Star reports that the defence lawyers were visibly shaking and MacGregor shouted out in relief. They left court with their client, a free man.
Key Takeaways
A Toronto jury acquitted a 28-year-old man of murder in the April 2023 shooting death of a 24-year-old former friend near Bloor Street West and Ossington Avenue
According to the Toronto Star, he was not the shooter and the Crown's case centred on an attempted kick caught on grainy video
A judge had earlier granted him bail on the murder charge, which the Star describes as a rare step
The jury deliberated about six hours, more than three years after his arrest
His defence lawyers call him 'completely innocent' and question why the case went to trial
UL Lawyers Insight
This case is a strong reminder of the presumption of innocence. In Canada, the Crown must establish every element of an offence beyond a reasonable doubt, and a jury that is left with a reasonable doubt must acquit. In general, Canadian law allows someone who did not personally use a weapon to be prosecuted as a party to an offence under section 21 of the Criminal Code. Courts have long held, however, that simply being present at the scene is not enough on its own.
The case also shows how long the process can take and what it can cost the people involved. Here, more than three years passed between arrest and verdict. A criminal acquittal and a civil lawsuit are separate processes with different rules. Questions about civil remedies, such as a claim for malicious prosecution, are very fact-specific and difficult to win, and they are best reviewed with experienced civil litigation lawyers. To learn more about how Ontario's courts work, our legal resource library offers plain-language guides.
Action Checklist
What You Should Do
Ask to speak to a lawyer immediately if arrested or detainedUrgent
Section 10(b) of the Charter guarantees your right to counsel without delay
Politely decline to answer police questions until you get legal adviceUrgent
You have a right to remain silent, and anything you say can be used as evidence
Preserve evidence such as videos, messages, receipts and witness namesUrgent
As this case shows, surveillance footage can be central at trial, and evidence can disappear quickly
Follow every bail condition exactlyUrgent
Breaching a release condition is a separate offence and can lead to being held in custody
Stay off social media about the caseUrgent
Posts and messages can be used in court and may be misread
Get advice on how the charge may affect your job or immigration status
A criminal matter can have consequences well beyond the courtroom
Note the two-year limitation period for any related civil claim
Ontario's Limitations Act, 2002 generally sets a two-year deadline for civil lawsuits
Your Rights and Options
Everyone charged with a crime in Ontario is protected by the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Under section 10(b), you have the right to speak to a lawyer without delay when you are arrested. Section 11(d) guarantees that you are presumed innocent until the Crown establishes guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Section 11(e) protects your right not to be denied reasonable bail without just cause. As this story shows, for murder charges, only a Superior Court judge can grant bail under section 522 of the Criminal Code.
If you were acquitted or your charges were withdrawn, any civil claim connected to the prosecution is generally subject to the two-year limitation period in Ontario's Limitations Act, 2002. A charge can also affect your job, your immigration status or your family matters. If you want to understand your options, you can request a consultation with our team.
Common Questions Answered
How UL Lawyers Can Help
Being accused of a crime, or watching someone you love go through it, can turn your life upside down. Waiting years for answers adds a heavy layer of stress. Our team does not handle every type of case, but we can help you make sense of how a criminal matter may affect other parts of your life, such as your employment, immigration status, or civil legal options. We will listen to your situation, explain things in plain language, and point you toward the right next steps. If you're unsure where to turn, reach out for a free, no-pressure consultation.
Wondering how a criminal charge could affect your job, immigration status or legal options? Talk to our team for clear, practical guidance.
Ontario Road Report
One email a week with the road and collision stories we covered in your city and across Ontario.
About this article:
Summary prepared with AI assistance from the linked source's reporting. Edited by UL Lawyers for Ontario context.
Accompanying images are AI-generated illustrations, not photographs of actual events or persons.
Important Legal Disclaimer
This page summarizes a news report about a Toronto murder trial that ended in an acquittal and provides general legal information only. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer-client relationship. Criminal and civil outcomes depend on the specific facts of each case. If you are facing a charge or considering legal action, please speak with a qualified Ontario lawyer about your situation.
Source: TorontoStar
Named in this article? Request content removal