Skip to main content

Search the site

Home/Resources/Can You Sue Someone for Hitting You With Their Car in Canada?

Motor Vehicle Law

Can You Sue Someone for Hitting You With Their Car in Canada?

·11 min read·Reviewed by Sunish Rai Uppal
Share
Can You Sue Someone for Hitting You With Their Car in Canada?

Being struck by a vehicle can turn your life upside down in seconds. Medical bills pile up, income disappears, and the at-fault driver’s insurer may already be building a case against you. One of the first questions injured Ontarians ask is simple and urgent: can I actually sue the person who hit me?

The short answer is yes — Ontario law gives injured people the right to pursue a civil lawsuit against a negligent driver. But the path from collision to compensation is not automatic. You must navigate Ontario’s mandatory insurance system, strict limitation periods, and a legal test that requires you to prove liability, causation, and the extent of your damages. Each of those three pillars can be contested, and insurers contest them aggressively.

This article explains how the right to sue works in a motor vehicle accident context — what you need to prove, how long you have to act, what damages are available, and what can go wrong. If you are dealing with an injury right now, our motor vehicle accident legal team is here to help you understand your options at no cost.

Table of Contents

Can You Sue Someone for Hitting You With Their Car in Canada?

Yes — in Ontario and across Canada, a person injured by a negligent driver may bring a civil lawsuit for damages. The legal foundation is the tort of negligence, which exists independently of the provincial insurance system. Even though Ontario operates a no-fault accident benefits scheme under the Insurance Act (which gives you access to Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule, or SABS, benefits regardless of fault), those benefits do not extinguish your right to sue the at-fault driver in court.

However, Ontario’s system does place one important threshold on lawsuits: to claim non-economic damages (like pain and suffering), your injury must meet the legal definition of a “permanent serious disfigurement” or a “permanent serious impairment of an important physical, mental, or psychological function.” This is called the verbal threshold, and it was introduced to screen out minor soft-tissue claims from the courts.

Who Can Be Sued?

  • The at-fault driver — the most common defendant
  • The vehicle owner — Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act makes vehicle owners potentially liable for negligent use of their car by another person
  • A municipality — if dangerous road design or poor maintenance contributed to the crash
  • An employer — if the driver was operating a vehicle in the course of employment
  • A commercial host or social host — in some circumstances where alcohol was involved

What About Contributory Negligence?

If you were partly at fault — say, you were jaywalking or not wearing a seatbelt — Ontario follows contributory negligence rules under the Negligence Act. Your damages are reduced in proportion to your share of fault, but you are not barred from suing entirely unless you were 100% responsible.

The bottom line: a collision on an Ontario road almost always gives rise to the right to sue. Whether that lawsuit succeeds, and for how much, depends on what you can prove.

Winning a Car Accident Lawsuit in Ontario

What Do You Need to Prove to Win a Motor Vehicle Accident Lawsuit?

Ontario courts use a three-part test for negligence. You — through your lawyer — must establish all three elements on a balance of probabilities (meaning it is more likely than not that each element is true).

1. Duty of Care

Every licensed driver in Canada owes a duty of care to other road users, cyclists, and pedestrians. This element is almost never seriously disputed in a motor vehicle case. The moment someone gets behind the wheel on a public road, the duty exists.

2. Breach of the Standard of Care (Liability)

You must show the defendant drove below the standard of a reasonably careful driver. Evidence used to prove breach can include:

  • Police collision reports — officers’ notes about charges, fault designations, or Highway Traffic Act violations
  • Photographs and video — dashcam footage, intersection cameras, bystander cell-phone video
  • Witness statements — independent bystanders carry significant weight
  • Accident reconstruction experts — retained for high-speed, fatal, or complex crashes
  • Electronic data — vehicle black-box data recording speed, braking, and steering inputs
  • Cell phone records — to establish distracted driving

Common breaches include speeding, running a red light, failing to yield, drunk or distracted driving, and failing to signal. A Highway Traffic Act conviction, though not binding on a civil court, is powerful supporting evidence.

3. Causation

This is often the most contested element. You must prove the defendant’s breach caused your injuries — not merely that the collision happened and you are now hurt. Insurers routinely argue that your symptoms stem from a pre-existing condition unrelated to the crash.

Strong causation evidence includes:

  • Emergency room records from the day of the collision
  • Treating physician notes documenting the onset and mechanism of injury
  • Imaging (X-rays, MRI, CT scans) obtained promptly after the accident
  • A physiatrist, orthopaedic surgeon, or neurologist opinion linking the injury mechanism to your diagnosis
  • A chronological gap analysis — showing you had no relevant complaints before the collision and developed them immediately after

4. Damages

Even with proven liability and causation, you must quantify your losses. Ontario courts can award:

  • Non-pecuniary general damages — pain, suffering, loss of enjoyment of life (subject to the verbal threshold and a statutory deductible under the Insurance Act)
  • Loss of income and future earning capacity — supported by employment records, tax returns, and vocational expert reports
  • Future care costs — a life-care planner or occupational therapist may project ongoing medical needs
  • Out-of-pocket expenses — prescription costs, travel for treatment, home adaptations
  • Family law claims — family members may claim loss of guidance, care, and companionship under the Family Law Act

Use our personal injury settlement calculator to get a rough sense of the range of damages that may apply to your situation — then speak with a lawyer to understand how the specific facts of your case affect that estimate.

What Are the Time Limits for Suing After a Car Accident?

Time limits in Ontario motor vehicle cases are strict, and missing them can permanently bar your claim.

The Basic Two-Year Limitation Period

The Limitations Act, 2002 sets a two-year limitation period for most civil claims. The clock generally starts on the date you discovered (or ought reasonably to have discovered) that you have a claim — which is usually the date of the collision itself. In most car accident cases, that means you have two years from the crash date to issue your statement of claim in court. Waiting to see whether you recover does not reliably pause that clock: in a 2026 Court of Appeal decision (2026 ONCA 434), a lawsuit was dismissed because the injured person knew, or ought to have known, that their injuries likely met the Insurance Act threshold well before they sued, even without a formal expert opinion.

Accident Benefits — 7-Day and 30-Day Deadlines

Separate from the lawsuit, SABS accident benefits under the Insurance Act have their own notice requirements. You must notify your own insurer of the accident promptly, and there are deadlines for submitting specific benefit applications. Missing an accident benefits deadline can affect your entitlement to those benefits, so act quickly.

Suing a Municipality — 10-Day Notice

If a dangerous road condition contributed to your accident and you intend to sue a municipality, the Municipal Act requires written notice to the municipality within 10 days of the accident. This is a very short window and is frequently missed without legal advice.

Minors and the Limitation Period

If the injured person is under 18, the two-year period does not begin until they turn 18 — but a litigation guardian can commence an action earlier on their behalf, and doing so early is usually in the minor’s best interest.

Why Acting Early Matters Beyond Deadlines

Even when you are well inside the two-year window, delay hurts your case. Witnesses’ memories fade, surveillance footage gets overwritten within days, skid marks disappear, and vehicle damage is repaired. A lawyer can send preservation letters to retain critical evidence before it is lost.

Key takeaway: Do not assume you have “plenty of time.” If you were injured in a motor vehicle accident, contact a lawyer as soon as you are physically able to do so.

What Are the Time Limits for Suing After a Car Accident?

How Does Ontario’s No-Fault Insurance System Affect Your Lawsuit?

Ontario’s auto insurance system has two parallel tracks, and understanding how they interact is essential.

Track 1 — Accident Benefits (No-Fault)

Regardless of who caused the crash, your own insurer must pay Statutory Accident Benefits (SABS): income replacement benefits, medical and rehabilitation benefits, attendant care, and others. These benefits are governed by Ontario’s Insurance Act and its regulations and are available to you even if you were at fault.

If your insurer denies or reduces your accident benefits, you may dispute that decision at the Licence Appeal Tribunal (LAT), an administrative body that hears SABS disputes.

Track 2 — The Tort Lawsuit

Separately, if another driver was at fault, you can sue them (and their insurer defends them) for damages beyond what SABS covers. The two tracks run simultaneously — accident benefits are not a reason to give up the tort claim.

The Deductible and Threshold

For claims that clear the verbal threshold, Ontario’s Insurance Act currently imposes a statutory deductible that is applied against general damages awards below a set amount. This deductible is adjusted periodically. A lawyer can confirm the current figure and advise whether your damages are likely to exceed it.

Subrogation

In some situations, your insurer may seek to recover from the at-fault driver’s insurer amounts they paid you in accident benefits — this is called subrogation. How subrogation interacts with your tort damages is a nuanced issue that an experienced car accident lawyer can help you navigate.

What Compensation Can You Realistically Expect?

The amount of compensation available in a motor vehicle accident lawsuit in Ontario varies enormously depending on the nature and severity of your injuries, your pre-accident income, your age, and the strength of your evidence. There is no single “average” figure that applies to all cases.

Factors That Increase Compensation

  • Severity and permanence of the injury (e.g., spinal cord injury, traumatic brain injury, serious orthopaedic fractures)
  • High pre-accident income that you can no longer earn
  • Young age — a longer period of lost earning capacity
  • Clear liability with no contributory negligence on your part
  • Well-documented treatment history from day one

Factors That Reduce Compensation

  • Pre-existing conditions in the same body region
  • Gaps in treatment that insurers argue show your injury was not serious
  • Contributory negligence (not wearing a seatbelt, speeding, distracted walking)
  • Failure to mitigate — not following your doctor’s treatment recommendations
  • Injuries that do not meet the verbal threshold, removing the right to general damages

Types of Awards

Damage Category Description
Non-pecuniary general damages Pain, suffering, loss of enjoyment
Loss of income (past) Wages lost between crash and trial
Loss of earning capacity (future) Projected income loss over career
Future care costs Medical, rehabilitation, attendant care
Special damages Out-of-pocket expenses, receipts required
Family Law Act claims Spouse/children’s loss of guidance and care

To get a personalised starting point, try our personal injury settlement calculator — but remember that a calculator cannot replace professional legal advice tailored to your file.

What Compensation Can You Realistically Expect?

What Should You Do Immediately After Being Hit by a Car?

The actions you take in the hours and days after a collision can make or break your lawsuit. Here is what matters most:

At the Scene

  1. Call 911 — Report the collision. A police report creates an official record.
  2. Get medical attention immediately — Even if you feel “okay,” adrenaline masks pain. Emergency records tie your injury to the event.
  3. Document everything — Photograph vehicle damage, road conditions, skid marks, traffic signals, and your visible injuries.
  4. Exchange information — Obtain the driver’s name, licence plate, insurer, and policy number.
  5. Gather witnesses — Names and contact information of bystanders who saw the collision.

In the Days Following

  • Notify your own insurer promptly — Ontario law requires timely notice of an accident.
  • See your family doctor and describe every symptom, no matter how minor it seems.
  • Keep a pain and symptoms journal — Daily notes of your limitations, pain levels, and how the injury affects your life are powerful evidence.
  • Save all receipts — Prescriptions, physiotherapy, taxi rides to appointments — everything.
  • Avoid posting on social media — Insurers monitor social media for posts that contradict your injury claims.

Consult a Lawyer Early

Most personal injury lawyers, including our team at UL Lawyers’ motor vehicle accident practice, offer free initial consultations and work on a contingency fee basis — meaning you pay no legal fees unless you recover compensation. Early legal advice helps preserve evidence and ensures you meet all critical deadlines.

How Much Can You Get for Pain and Suffering After a Car Accident in Ontario?

Pain and suffering compensation — formally called non-pecuniary general damages — is often the largest single head of damages in a motor vehicle accident lawsuit, yet it is also the most heavily regulated in Ontario. Understanding both the ceiling and the deductible is essential before forming any expectations.

The Supreme Court “Trilogy” Cap

Canadian courts trace the upper limit of non-pecuniary general damages to a trio of Supreme Court of Canada decisions from 1978, commonly called the trilogy. The cap set in those cases has been indexed to inflation over the decades and now sits at roughly $440,000–$450,000. Only the most catastrophic injuries — such as severe traumatic brain injury or permanent quadriplegia — approach that ceiling.

Ontario’s Statutory Threshold

Ontario’s Insurance Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. I.8, and O. Reg. 461/96 impose a threshold test: to recover any non-pecuniary damages in a tort claim, the plaintiff must prove that the impairment resulting from the accident was:

  • Permanent and serious in nature, or
  • Resulted in death.

Courts assess permanence and seriousness based on medical evidence, functional limitations, and the effect on the plaintiff’s daily life and enjoyment of activities. Soft-tissue injuries that fully resolve generally do not meet the threshold.

The Statutory Deductible

Even when a plaintiff clears the threshold, Ontario’s Insurance Act mandates that a statutory deductible be subtracted from the non-pecuniary damages award. This deductible is adjusted each calendar year by regulation; for recent years it has exceeded $46,000. Critically, the deductible disappears entirely if the award surpasses a separate (higher) regulatory cap — meaning very large awards are paid in full, while mid-range awards are reduced.

Example (illustrative only): An award of $80,000 in general damages, minus the deductible, might result in a net recovery in the range of $30,000–$35,000. An award of $300,000 would not be reduced at all.

Where Most Real Claims Actually Land

In practice, the range of outcomes is wide:

Injury Profile Approximate General Damages Range*
Soft-tissue / whiplash (threshold met) $30,000 – $100,000
Moderate orthopaedic / chronic pain $80,000 – $175,000
Serious brain or spinal injury $175,000 – $350,000
Catastrophic (paralysis, severe TBI) $350,000 – cap (~$450,000)

*These are illustrative ranges drawn from reported Ontario decisions. Every case turns on its own facts, medical evidence, and credibility findings. No specific outcome is guaranteed.

Pain and Suffering Is Not Your Only Remedy

Non-pecuniary damages are only one component of a full tort claim. Lost income (past and future), medical and rehabilitation expenses, housekeeping costs, and — where applicable — a Family Law Act R.S.O. 1990, c. F.3 claim by close family members for loss of care, guidance, and companionship can substantially increase overall recovery, sometimes far beyond the general damages award itself.

Ontario vs. the Rest of Canada

The trilogy cap applies across all Canadian common-law provinces, so the ceiling is essentially the same nationwide. What differs by province is the threshold mechanism and deductible. Quebec operates under a distinct civil-law framework with its own SAAQ no-fault scheme. Ontario’s combination of a strict threshold and a large deductible means net general damages awards here can be lower than equivalent awards in provinces such as British Columbia or Alberta, where no comparable deductible applies. If your accident occurred outside Ontario, the applicable rules will differ — another reason to speak with a lawyer familiar with the law of the relevant province.

Talk to a UL Lawyers Team Member

If you or someone you love was injured in a motor vehicle accident in Ontario, you do not have to face the insurance system alone. Our team offers a free, no-obligation consultation — we will listen to what happened, explain your rights, and tell you honestly what your options are. Contact UL Lawyers today, because every day you wait is a day closer to a deadline you cannot afford to miss.

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about motor vehicle accident in Ontario.

Can I sue a driver if I was partly at fault for the accident?

Yes. Ontario follows contributory negligence rules under the Negligence Act. If you were partially at fault — for example, you were crossing outside a crosswalk — your damages award is reduced by your percentage of fault, but you are not automatically barred from recovering anything. Only if you were found 100% responsible would you recover nothing. A lawyer can help assess how fault may be apportioned in your specific circumstances and what that means for your potential recovery.

What is the verbal threshold and does my injury meet it?

Ontario's Insurance Act limits who can claim pain and suffering damages in a motor vehicle lawsuit. Your injury must qualify as a permanent serious disfigurement or a permanent serious impairment of an important physical, mental, or psychological function. Soft-tissue injuries that fully resolve generally do not meet this threshold. Serious fractures, traumatic brain injuries, spinal cord injuries, and chronic pain conditions often do. A medical-legal assessment by a specialist, combined with legal analysis, is needed to determine whether your injury clears the threshold.

How long does a car accident lawsuit take in Ontario?

Most motor vehicle accident lawsuits in Ontario take two to five years from the date the claim is issued to resolution — either through a negotiated settlement or a trial verdict. Many cases settle before trial, often after examinations for discovery where both sides question each other under oath. Complex cases involving catastrophic injuries or disputed liability may take longer. Acting early with a lawyer helps move the file forward efficiently and positions you for the strongest possible outcome.

Do I still need to sue if I have accident benefits?

Accident benefits under Ontario's SABS provide income replacement, medical, and rehabilitation benefits from your own insurer, regardless of fault. However, they have limits and may not fully compensate you for lost income, future care needs, or pain and suffering. The tort lawsuit against the at-fault driver can recover damages that go beyond what SABS covers. The two claims run on parallel tracks — having accident benefits does not prevent you from also pursuing the at-fault driver in court.

What if the at-fault driver has no insurance?

Ontario law protects you even if the at-fault driver is uninsured or unidentified (a hit-and-run). Your own auto insurance policy must include uninsured automobile coverage, which allows you to make a claim against your own insurer as though they were the at-fault driver's insurer. The Motor Vehicle Accident Claims Fund administered through the Ontario government may also provide compensation as a last resort. A lawyer can guide you through the specific rules that apply in uninsured and hit-and-run situations.

How much can you get for pain and suffering after being hit by a car in Ontario?

In Ontario tort claims, general damages for pain and suffering ("non-pecuniary general damages") are subject to two hurdles. First, your injury must meet the statutory threshold — it must be permanent and serious, as defined under the Insurance Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. I.8. Second, a statutory deductible (adjusted annually; currently over $46,000 for most claims) is subtracted from the award unless it exceeds a higher cap. Awards that survive both hurdles can range from modest five-figure sums for soft-tissue injuries up to roughly $450,000 — the Supreme Court of Canada's trilogy ceiling, indexed for inflation — for the most catastrophic cases. Actual recovery depends heavily on injury severity, prognosis, and the evidence presented. No specific outcome can be guaranteed.

Relevant next step

Talk to a motor vehicle accident lawyer

If your article involves a crash, injury, or claim dispute, get advice on compensation and claim value.

Call 905-744-8888 or email info@ullaw.ca. Consultations are free for injury and disability matters. On other matters, the first 15 minutes are free.

REQUEST A CONSULTATION

All fields are required unless noted. Your information stays confidential.

Why Us

Why Choose UL Lawyers

  • Decades of combined experience
  • Serving clients across Ontario
  • Clear, transparent fee structures
  • Responsive, client-focused counsel
  • Tailored legal strategies

Keep Reading

More resources
you might like.