

When an appeal court orders a new trial, it is protecting the fairness of the process, not deciding the outcome. For families of crime victims, it's important to know that civil deadlines may keep running while a criminal case works its way through appeals and retrials.
A Toronto jury has again found three men guilty of first-degree murder in the 2018 shooting death of a 26-year-old electrical engineer in Etobicoke. Jurors reached their verdict early Wednesday evening at a retrial ordered after Ontario's Court of Appeal set aside the men's original 2020 convictions. For anyone following legal developments in Ontario, the case shows how an error at trial can send a case back to a brand-new jury years later.
According to the Toronto Star, the shooting happened on March 16, 2018, at Scarlettwood Court, a housing complex in Etobicoke. At around 11 p.m., the young man was walking to his car after a visit at the complex. Two men got out of an SUV, followed him for less than a minute, then drew handguns and shot at him nine times. He was struck five times and died at the scene.
The prosecution alleged that the three men agreed to go to Scarlettwood Court to shoot and kill someone, with two of them acting as the shooters and the third as the driver. Toronto police put together extensive surveillance video that, as described by the Star, shows the three travelling from Martha Eaton Way to a parking lot, where they got into a stolen Nissan Rogue carrying stolen licence plates. They then drove to Scarlettwood Court and circled the complex. The Star reports that surveillance video later captured the men celebrating. Prosecutors described the killing as a "ruthless execution."
This jury did not hear what the Crown saw as a crucial piece of its case. At the first trial, prosecutors alleged the three were gang members who targeted the victim simply because he was going about his life in a rival gang's neighbourhood. That allegation was not put before the second jury. Jurors were told the case was a retrial but were instructed not to draw any conclusions from that or to ask why. The Court of Appeal had overturned the first convictions after finding critical errors in the jury instructions about the Criminal Code.
The three men will resume serving mandatory life sentences. The victim's mother, who attended the trial throughout, was scheduled to deliver a victim impact statement on Thursday, her second time doing so. Det.-Sgt. Jason Shankaran, the lead detective on the case, told the Star by text message that reliving the circumstances of the death had clearly been hard on the family, but that they had shown remarkable strength. He added that two separate juries had now reached the same conclusion on the essential facts, which he said reflected the strength of the evidence and the passion and skill of the Crown attorneys.
Key Takeaways
Three men were found guilty of first-degree murder again at a retrial over the March 16, 2018 shooting at Scarlettwood Court in Etobicoke.
Ontario's Court of Appeal had set aside their 2020 convictions over critical errors in jury instructions about the Criminal Code.
The second jury did not hear the Crown's allegation that the victim was targeted because he was in a rival gang's neighbourhood.
The three men will resume serving mandatory life sentences.
The victim's mother was scheduled to deliver a victim impact statement for a second time.
Ontario families affected by violent crime have a right to be heard and may have access to support programs and civil options.
UL Lawyers Insight
This case is a reminder that Ontario's appeal courts look closely at whether a trial was fair, not just at the outcome. When the Court of Appeal finds an error in how a jury was instructed on the law, it can order a new trial, even years later. A retrial is decided only on the evidence the new jury is allowed to hear, which is why the Crown's earlier gang allegation played no part this time.
For families who lose a loved one to violent crime, a retrial can mean reliving painful details all over again. Canadian law gives victims and their families a right to be heard, including through victim impact statements at sentencing. Families may also have options outside the criminal courts. A criminal verdict is separate from any civil claim, and speaking with experienced litigation lawyers can help a family understand whether a civil claim is possible. Families often also need to settle their loved one's affairs after a sudden death, where guidance on handling a loved one's estate can ease the burden.
Action Checklist
What You Should Do
Connect with Ontario's Victim/Witness Assistance ProgramUrgent
Staff can keep you informed about court dates, retrials and sentencing, and explain what to expect in court.
Apply for help through the Victim Quick Response Program+Urgent
Eligible families may receive support for funeral costs, counselling and other immediate expenses, and some supports have application deadlines.
Get legal advice on civil claim deadlinesUrgent
The Limitations Act, 2002 generally allows two years, and a long criminal case does not automatically pause that clock.
Prepare your victim impact statement
Write down how the loss has affected you emotionally, physically and financially so you are ready to share it at sentencing.
Keep records of expenses and lost income
Save receipts for funeral costs, counselling and travel to court, and track any lost wages, which may matter for support programs or a civil claim.
Register for offender information with federal authorities
Victims and family members of people serving federal sentences can register to receive updates on parole hearings and related decisions.
Address your loved one's estate
Locate any will, identify the executor or next steps for administration, and seek guidance if there is no will.
Your Rights and Options
If someone you love is killed by a violent crime in Ontario, the law gives you a voice. The Canadian Victims Bill of Rights protects your right to information about the case and to take part in the process. Section 722 of the Criminal Code lets family members give a victim impact statement at sentencing, as the victim's mother in this case was set to do for a second time after the retrial. Ontario's Victim Quick Response Program+ may help eligible families with costs such as funeral expenses and counselling.
Criminal verdicts and civil claims run on separate tracks. Under section 61 of Ontario's Family Law Act, certain family members may claim compensation for losses when a relative is killed through someone else's wrongful act. The Limitations Act, 2002 generally sets a two-year deadline for civil claims, and a long criminal process, including an appeal and retrial like this one, does not automatically pause that clock. If you are unsure where you stand, you can request a free consultation to review your options.
Common Questions Answered
How UL Lawyers Can Help
Losing someone to violence is devastating, and sitting through a trial, or a second one, can reopen wounds you thought were starting to heal. You should not have to sort out legal questions on your own while you grieve. At UL Lawyers, we help families across Mississauga, Brampton, Toronto and the GTA understand their options after a sudden loss. That can include reviewing whether a civil claim may be possible, explaining important deadlines, and guiding you through managing your loved one's estate. We will listen first and explain things in plain language. If you have questions, reach out for a free, no-pressure consultation.
If your family is coping with the loss of a loved one to violent crime and you are unsure about your options or deadlines, we're here to help you understand them, free and without pressure.
Ontario Road Report
One email a week with the road and collision stories we covered in your city and across Ontario.
About this article:
Summary prepared with AI assistance from the linked source's reporting. Edited by UL Lawyers for Ontario context.
Accompanying images are AI-generated illustrations, not photographs of actual events or persons.
Important Legal Disclaimer
This page provides general information about a criminal retrial reported in the news and about the rights of crime victims' families in Ontario. It is not legal advice, and UL Lawyers is not involved in this case. Victim supports, civil claims and limitation periods depend on your specific circumstances, so please speak with a qualified Ontario lawyer about your situation.
Source: TorontoStar
Named in this article? Request content removal