Skip to main content
Home / News / New Trial Ordered in 1989 Toronto Murder Case

New Trial Ordered in 1989 Toronto Murder Case

November 27, 2025
Updated November 27, 2025 at 04:32 p.m.
3 min read
CityNews Toronto
Share:
Courtroom with judges and lawyers discussing a case, relevant to the Ontario legal system.

Courtroom with judges and lawyers discussing a case, relevant to the Ontario legal system.

The Court of Appeal for Ontario has ordered a new trial for Timothy Rees, who was convicted in 1990 of killing 10-year-old Darla Thurrott in Toronto. The court's decision came after it was revealed that crucial evidence, including a taped conversation between a police officer and the victim's landlord, was not disclosed during the original trial. This evidence could have supported the defense's argument that the landlord, who lived in the same home as the victim, was a potential third-party suspect.

"This case illustrates the critical role of evidence disclosure in ensuring just legal outcomes."

Legal Perspective: Ensuring all evidence is available and considered is fundamental to upholding the right to a fair trial.

Key Takeaways

A new trial has been ordered for a 1989 murder case.

Undisclosed evidence prompted the decision.

This case emphasizes the importance of fair trial rights.

What This Means for Ontario Residents

For Ontario residents, this case highlights the importance of fair trial rights and the impact of undisclosed evidence on the justice system. The decision underscores the necessity for transparency in legal proceedings, which can significantly affect the outcome of a trial and the freedom of individuals. This case serves as a reminder of the possible need for legal review in situations where new evidence emerges, impacting past convictions.

What You Should Do

1

Review all evidence related to your case

Ensure no key evidence has been overlooked or undisclosed

2

Consult a lawyer if new evidence emerges Urgent

Legal guidance can help assess the impact of new evidence

3

Document any new findings thoroughly Urgent

Detailed records can support your case in appeals

4

Understand your rights to appeal

Knowing your legal options is crucial if new evidence surfaces

5

Request a case review if concerned about trial fairness

A legal professional can help evaluate past proceedings

Your Rights and Options

If you're involved in a legal case, it's crucial to ensure that all relevant evidence is disclosed and considered. Ontario residents have the right to a fair trial, and undisclosed evidence can significantly impact this right. If you believe that new evidence could affect a legal decision in your case, reaching out to legal professionals can help you understand your options and potentially appeal the decision.

Common Questions Answered

How UL Lawyers Can Help

Navigating the complexities of the legal system can be challenging, especially when new evidence comes to light. At UL Lawyers, we understand the stress that such situations can cause and are committed to providing compassionate, knowledgeable support. Our team can help review your case, identify potential issues, and guide you through the legal process. Contact us for a free consultation to discuss your situation and explore your legal options.

Have questions about how new evidence might affect your case? Our legal team is here to help you explore your options.

Important Legal Disclaimer

This summary is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For personalized legal assistance, please consult a qualified attorney.